World Beer Cup
- Blushing Star: Gold, Brett Beer Category (2016)
American Distilling Institute
- Fernet Michaud: Double Gold, Best of Category (2017) / Bronze, Excellence in Packaging (2017) / Bronze (2018) / Silver (2016)
- Old Port Single Malt Whiskey: Silver, Malt Whiskey Aged 1-2 Years (2016)
- Dow’s Demise Dark Rum: Bronze, Aged Rum – Other Sugar (2016)
San Francisco World Spirits Competition
- Old Port Straight Bourbon Whiskey: Gold (2018) / Bronze (2019)
- Old Port Single Malt Whiskey: Silver (2018) / Bronze (2017)
- Old Port Straight Rye Whiskey: Bronze (2019)
- Fernet Michaud: Silver (2018) / Bronze (2019, 2017)
- Portland Rum Riot Rum: Silver (2019)
- Bierschnaps: Silver (2019)
- Bonfire Spirit: Silver (2017)
New York International Spirits Competition
- Fernet Michaud: Gold (2020)
New York World Spirits Competition
- Old Port Straight Bourbon Whiskey: Silver (2018)
- Fernet Michaud: Bronze (2018)
American Craft Spirits Association
- Fernet Michaud: Silver (2017 / Bronze (2016)
- Bonfire Spirit: Bronze (2017)
- Old Port Rye Whiskey: Bronze (2016)
- Old Port Single Malt Whiskey: Bronze (2016)
Great American Spirits Festival
- Old Port Straight Rye Whiskey: Silver (2015)
U.S. Open Whiskey & Spirits Championship
- Dow’s Demise Dark Rum: Silver (2020)
- Fernet Michaud: Bronze (2020)
RateBeer
- Best Brewpub in Maine (2018, 2017, 2016, 2015, 2014, 2013)
Good Food Awards
- Persuasion: Finalist, Beer, East Region (2020)
- Vinlandic: Finalist, Beers, East Region (2020)
- Old Port Straight Rye Whiskey: Finalist, Spirits, East Region (2020)
- Blushing Star: Winner, Beer, East Region (2019)
- Fernet Michaud: Winner, Spirits, East Region (2019)
- Old Port Straight Bourbon Whiskey: Winner, Spirits, East Region (2019)